Customer Reviews

"The meatzza pizza and garlic bread with cheese were truly among the best I've ever had! The pizza came out hot and fresh, loaded with toppings. Absolutely incredible. 10/10 recommend!"

via Google Reviews

"Absolute hands down best pizza around, very well known small town secret. Consistently good with bear paw seasoning - there's something that just makes you want more and more and more!"

via Yelp

"I used to get this pizza once a week when I worked in Lancaster, and now we make special trips from Columbus just to satisfy our Sugar Bears craving! That sweet sauce is addictive!"

via Yelp

"Everything is AMAZING here as always. Love love the sweeter sauces when it comes to my pizzas AND this is a family owned and operated local pizzeria and I always support that as I am a local!"

via Yelp

"I love pizza and have tried so many different pizzas over the years but I have to say I love Sugar Bears and its my favorite by far. Friendly staff and the food is always consistently good and fresh."

via TripAdvisor

"We were in town visiting family and this place came highly recommended. The sweetness of the sauce went well with the fresh toppings, especially the vegetables. We found the thickness of the pizza to be perfect!"

via TripAdvisor

"Small locally owned shop. Great food with great service. Best Pizza in Lancaster. I highly recommend it!"

via TripAdvisor

"Who doesn't love pizza, right? Part of my retirement is to find the best pizza in the USA. The sauce was sweet and tasted amazing. Toppings edge to edge. Crust was thin and done just right. This is a definite repeat in my book!"

via TripAdvisor

"This is our family's favorite pizza in Lancaster! We order from here all the time and it never disappoints. The quality is always consistent!"

via MenuPix

"Best pizza ever!!!!! Best customer service too!!! Absolutely love this place."

via MenuPix

"The pizza is absolutely great. The subs are very good too. This is my go-to place in Lancaster!"

via MenuPix

"Best pizza in Lancaster! Love that they aren't stingy with the pizza sauce. They usually put a lot of sauce on it and that's just the way I like it!"

via MenuPix