Family-owned and operated since 2011
Since opening our doors in 2011, Sugar Bears Pizzeria has been a labor of love for our family. What started as a dream to bring exceptional pizza to Lancaster has grown into a beloved local favorite, where quality and community come together in every slice.
We're proud to be a family-owned and operated business, where every pizza is made with the same care and attention we'd give to our own family's dinner. From the moment you walk through our door or call to place an order, you're not just a customer – you're part of the Sugar Bears family.
Our commitment is simple: use fresh, quality ingredients, never skimp on toppings, and always serve our food with a smile. We believe that great pizza brings people together, and we're honored to be part of your family gatherings, celebrations, and everyday meals.
Located at 147 Cedar Hill Rd in Lancaster, our cozy pizzeria may be small, but our passion for great food and excellent service is huge. We're grateful for every customer who has supported us over the years, and we look forward to serving you for many more to come!
We're a true family operation, and we treat every customer like they're part of our extended family. Your satisfaction is our top priority.
We source the freshest ingredients and never cut corners. Every pizza is loaded with toppings from edge to edge.
Whether it's your first visit or your hundredth, you can count on the same great taste every single time. That's our promise.
Lancaster is our home, and we're proud to serve our neighbors. Supporting local has always been at the heart of what we do.
Our signature Bear Paw pizza isn't just a menu item – it's the heart of Sugar Bears Pizzeria. What makes it so special? It's our secret Bear Paw seasoning blend that we sprinkle on every pie.
"Absolute hands down best pizza around, very well known small town secret. Consistently good with bear paw seasoning – there's something that just makes you want more and more and more!"
Combined with our slightly sweet pizza sauce, fresh toppings, and perfectly crispy crust, it creates a flavor profile that keeps customers coming back week after week. Some drive all the way from Columbus just to get their Sugar Bears fix!
The recipe has been perfected over years of trial and love, and it's something we guard closely. But the real secret? It's made with passion and served with a smile.
For over a decade, we've had the privilege of serving the wonderful people of Lancaster and surrounding areas. We've been there for birthday parties, family dinners, game nights, and everything in between. Seeing familiar faces walk through our door never gets old, and meeting new customers is always a joy.
We're grateful for the support this community has shown us, and we're committed to giving back by providing the best pizza experience possible, every single time.
Stop by and taste the difference that family-owned quality makes.
Visit Us Today